Insights · Pricing

Why one discount for everyone costs more than you think

November 7, 20265 min readWow Deals team

"20% off everything" is the easiest promotion to run. One code, one banner, done. But the simple setup hides a cost most stores never measure.

The shopper who was going to buy anyway

Picture three shoppers on your product page. The first has already decided to buy. The second is close, but unsure. The third is just browsing.

A store-wide code gives all three the same 20%. The first shopper did not need it, so that discount is money you gave away for nothing. The third shopper may not buy at any price today. Only the second shopper was really moved by the offer.

The bigger and more general the discount, the more of it lands on people who needed it least.

Shoppers learn to wait

When the same discount comes back often, shoppers notice. They add items to a cart and wait for the next code. Over time, your full price starts to feel like a price nobody pays.

This is hard to see in a single month's report, because the sales still come in. They just come in at a lower price.

Margin is not the same on every product

A flat 20% treats every product the same. But a product with a thin margin can turn a sale into a loss at 20%, while a product with a healthy margin could have handled more. One number for the whole store is almost always wrong for most of it.

What to do instead

1. Set a floor per product

Decide the least you are happy to sell each product for. A rule for a whole collection gets you most of the way there quickly. Then adjust the few products that need it.

2. Vary the offer

Not every shopper needs the biggest deal. Small offers, free shipping or a bundle can be enough to tip a decision. Keep your best price for a few.

3. Offer it to people who ask

An offer behind a button only reaches shoppers who show interest. That keeps it away from people who were going to buy at full price anyway, and it feels like a nice surprise instead of a constant sale.

4. Measure against no offer

The only fair test is to compare shoppers who saw offers with shoppers who did not. Then you know whether your deals bring in more revenue, or just give money away.

How Wow Deals does thisYou set the lowest price per product. Each interested shopper gets a different deal inside that room, and a share of visitors sees no offers so your report can compare both. See all features.